Socialholic

Caught in a web of social media

Techtastic 2011? Please let it get better than Pushnote!

with 4 comments

Hasn’t it been an exciting few weeks in the land of tech?  First Quora hits a PR perfect storm despite being nothing more than a dreadfully self important Twitter wiki without the message length constraint (everybody wants to be first with something big because they missed Twitter – folks, Quora isn’t it!!) and now Twitter Lord, Stephen Fry, launches Pushnote (a start-up he has invested in).

Pushnote is the latest in the deluge of disappointment which is engulfing the web.  Pishnote is described as an extra ‘layer’ on the web where you can leave comments.  And other Pishnote users can comment on your comments.  Imagine the possibilities! *yawn*

I could literally go on Twitter, bring up Pishnote and comment on someone’s Tweet and then someone could comment on my comment to the Tweet and then… oh, wait a minute, I could just do that on Twitter!  Ok, how about on Facebook, someone could leave a comment and I could leave a Pishnote comment… no, that doesn’t work, I could just do that on Facebook. How about a blog? Nope – you can do that either directly or with a dozen other tools.

One idea that has been touted about is to use it to comment on news stories – notwithstanding that news pages are often dynamic and, in any case, many have their own comment apps already.

Other ‘great’ things about Pishnote are that the Twitter integration is flakey and the comments do not thread or add themselves in any sort of logical order (unless you have a sufficiently bad case of OCD that you think that comments should be arranged in alphabetical order by the first letter of the commenter’s name – rather than say, in the order they are posted!).

Pishnote is bad. Let’s make no mistake about it.  Stephen Fry has put some money in it and he was due to launch it today (although that hasn’t happened by the looks of it) – so it is is getting a great reaction from people who are trying to ingratiate themselves with the lovely cuddly polymath.  But a few hundred people wittering about how clever Stephen Fry not only does him no favours, it also does not guarantee the success of something that is quite this awful.

Possibly on some level it was a good idea.  Let’s give it that.  But the reality is that it is awful – bad UI, bad browser integration, bad comment organisation, just bad.

…actually, it’s a bad idea too.

Google Buzz looks like the mutt’s nuts next to this.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks

Written by James

January 13th, 2011 at 5:00 pm

  • http://twitter.com/cosmictimevans/statuses/25605684720570368 cosmictimevans (Tim Evans)

    Techtastic 2011? Please let it get better than Pushnote! at Socialholic: http://www.socialholic.co.uk/?p=544

  • http://twitter.com/jamesmb/statuses/25652579169996800 jamesmb (jamesmb)

    @Coco_O just took another look at it. still awful! blogged it http://www.socialholic.co.uk/?p=544

  • http://twitter.com/jamesmb/statuses/25657896800882688 jamesmb (jamesmb)

    @Kesiahosking Good question!! http://www.socialholic.co.uk/?p=544 < my blog explains. well, moans. but kinda explains! :)

  • http://topsy.com/trackback?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.socialholic.co.uk%2F%3Fp%3D544&utm_source=pingback&utm_campaign=L2 Tweets that mention Techtastic 2011? Please let it get better than Pushnote! at Socialholic — Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by jamesmb, jamesmb, jamesmb, jamesmb, jamesmb and others. jamesmb said: Techtastic 2011? Please let it get better than Pushnote! http://bit.ly/gkosvH [...]